Tenet, CHS duel on conference calls

Pursued and pursuer reference still-alive acquisition offer; CHS' pipeline 'as deep as it's ever been'
Feb 25, 2011 11:22 AM

What CHS' Pennslyvania deal means

Community Health System's planned acquisition of Mercy Health Partners in northeastern Pennsylvania should add about 3 cents per share to the company's annual earnings before any efficiency gains, according to Whit Mayo of R.W. Baird, who estimates the three-hospital system's annual revenues at $184 million and EBITDA at $8 million. But perhaps more importantly, Mayo wrote in a research note to investors, is the fact that this deal signals CHS (Ticker: CYH) will remain an active consolidator in the industry, regardless of what happens with its hostile acquisition bid for Texas-based Tenet Healthcare Corp. Of course...
The bull-case for CYH remains grounded in the potential takeout of THC and the significant EPS power generated from the deal ($4.50+ EPS). We think as long as the market continues to view this deal with a high probability of success, our view is that CYH shares can likely move easily toward $45 (10x newco EPS).
Feb 11, 2011 9:14 AM

CHS buying PA health system

Mercy Health increases company's Keystone holdings to 12
Feb 10, 2011 3:26 PM

Tenet shareholders sue over denied CHS bid

Tenet Healthcare shareholders have filed a lawsuit against the Dallas company's board, claiming they breached their fiduciary duty by preventing a takeover by Franklin-based Community Health Systems. The Dallas Business Journal has the story:
The lawsuit names former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush as the lead defendant along with nine other Tenet board members. The suit, filed by a union pension fund, claims Bush and Tenet's other board members fought off a merger offer from Community Health Services by changing company bylaws. The suit claims the board members adopted a poison pill takeover defense under the pretext of protecting an alleged "tax asset" — an operating loss — to entrench themselves in their positions at shareholders' expense.
Community Health Systems (Ticker: CYH) made a $7.3 billion unsolicited bid for Tenet in November. Tenet (Ticker: THC) rebuffed the company and altered its bylaws and shareholder rights agreement to try and prevent a hostile takeover.
Feb 2, 2011 11:52 AM

Top CHS investor keeping the faith

New Jersey-based Franklin Mutual Advisers bought a few more shares of Community Health Systems (Ticker: CYH) in the fourth quarter to go with the 8.8 million it owned on Sept. 30. Franklin now owns 9.6 percent of Franklin-based CHS, which is bidding to buy rival Tenet Healthcare.
Jan 28, 2011 7:40 AM

Smith jabs at Tenet during analyst panel

While moderating the Nashville Health Care Council’s Wall Street panel today, Community Health Systems CEO Wayne Smith seized several opportunities to reference his company’s so-far-thwarted attempt to acquire Tenet Healthcare Corp. It started with a discussion of quality measures. Smith asked the panelists why they aren’t much interested in hospitals' quality initiatives, and in response, Avondale Partners analyst Kemp Dolliver referenced Tenet. Here's a piece of the conversation:

Dolliver: We look at Tenet, just to pick a name that’s focused on quality… Laughter, rumbling from the crowd Dolliver: Tenet had, they promoted Centers of Excellence and did all these quality things with payers... Smith (interrupting): They did? Dolliver: But they’ll tell you… Smith (interrupting): Did it help their stock price any?

Dolliver stumbled for a minute, then said Tenet’s volume growth improved somewhat, but that the company will tell you they didn’t get the bang for their buck on the program. And with that, the conversation moved on, until Smith circled back: "That company you were mentioning earlier has said a lot about taking market share because of their demonstrated quality, but they've had 26 straight quarters of reducing commercial enrollment. I'm not sure that's my definition of taking market share." Later in the discussion, Smith prompted analysts to talk about their favorite stocks for the year and any “events that could happen in 2011 that could enhance the industry and bring up the multiples and all of that.” Only Frank Morgan of RBC Capital took the bait, saying if “a particular company here in Nashville got interested in a company in, let’s say Texas and actually completed a transaction,” that, coupled HCA going public, could give the industry a big lift. Finally, Smith closed by telling the crowd: “We will prevail.”
Jan 26, 2011 3:04 PM
 |

Tenet responds to CHS

Community Health Systems on Friday named the 10 individuals it plans to nominate to acquisition target Tenet Healthcare's board of directors in November. Tenet, of course, issued a response not long after. In its entirety, from Tenet's release:
We believe that Community Health has nominated its slate of director candidates only to advance its goal of acquiring Tenet at an inadequate price. We are confident that the continued execution of our strategic plan will deliver significantly more value to our stockholders than Community Health’s inadequate proposal. Under the Board’s leadership, Tenet has delivered strong growth for more than five years, including solid performance in fiscal year 2010. Tenet continues to expect significant growth from a combination of acute care revenues, our expanding outpatient business, offering healthcare services to other hospitals, improved cost efficiencies, expanded margins and strategic investments. We look forward to building on our momentum in the year ahead. We firmly believe that Tenet’s stockholders – not Community Health – deserve to benefit from this growth. Tenet’s Board and management team will continue to act in the best interests of all its stockholders, and remain focused on executing our core business plan and capitalizing on Tenet’s leading position in healthcare services.
Jan 17, 2011 8:56 AM

CHS names Tenet board nominees

Franklin company continues acquisition pursuit
Jan 14, 2011 12:11 PM

Analyst action: Community Health, HealthSpring

Analyst John Ransom at Raymond James yesterday upgraded shares of Community Health Systems (Ticker: CYH) from 'market perform' to 'outperform.' He also boosted CHS' acquisition target Tenet Healthcare from 'market perform' to 'outperform' and raised his price on the shares (Ticker: THC) to $8. Both companies made presentations to investors yesterday. At Wedbush Securities, analyst Sarah James has upgraded shares of local Medicare Advantage plan provider HealthSpring from 'neutral' to 'outperform' with a price target of $33. James writes that the market isn't looking past current issues to the longer-term growth potential of the Medicare Advantage market. The move has helped lift HealthSpring shares (Ticker: HS) well above $30, a level they cracked briefly for the first time ever yesterday.
Jan 12, 2011 12:59 PM

Wayne Smith getting 'love letters' about Tenet deal

At the JP Morgan Healthcare Conference yesterday, Community Health Systems CEO Wayne Smith provided much commentary — some old, some colorfully new — on his company’s $7.3 billion acquisition offer for Tenet Healthcare Corp. Speaking to investors on the same day Tenet's CEO spoke out against CHS' bid, Smith reiterated several points he’s made in the past — that CHS thinks the Tenet buy is a good fit, that it's strategically compelling, that the company is committed to completing the transaction, and that Smith wishes he hadn’t had to take the offer public to (unsuccessfully) force Tenet to the negotiating table. Then there were a few new gems: “We think this is a very attractive offer we made. It had a 40 percent premium. I’m not sure what was wrong with it, but we were soundly rejected,” Smith said, referring to the first rejection letter from Tenet. “The second letter hurt my feelings, but it has not discouraged me at all.” Smith said the market has reacted positively to the deal, pushing CHS’ stock price (Ticker: CYH) upward. “It seems like everyone in America thinks this is a good idea except Trevor and the Tenet board,” he said. In fact, Smith said he’s been getting “love letters” from people around the country for pushing up the industry’s multiples. “I’m probably HCA’s most favorite son,” he said. And though some have said CHS will have to sweeten its offer in the future, Smith said the company is holding firm on its $6 per share price. Given that Tenet has refused to come to the negotiating table, and that it’s been paying 40 cents on the dollar for acquisitions in the past two years, he said CHS “may be overpaying” at $6 per share — “Who knows?”
Jan 12, 2011 7:00 AM
 |